Sunday, 9 December 2012

The green economy: Re-thinking global governance


This week I found a speech made by Achim Steiner , a German expert in environmental politics. In His article he talks about  the situation  in our planet and in our  society, after the social, cultural and economic development. Steiner  wrote that we live in a planet where the climatic changes and the loss of productive ecosystems can interrupt the global chains of provisioning. We depend of the our society and the effect that it  produced, in particular the poor people. In fact thanks to all these changes we have saved a lot of people from the poverty in the countries such as India. He wrote that there are two principals themes: the green economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication and an institutional framework for sustainable development.  A lot people think that the green economy represent the logical evolution for sustainable development, the need for all peoples. The European Commission explain that the renewable energies could cut primary energies demand by 9% by 2020 and close to 40% by 2050. Steiner explain the point of view in general, not his point of view; explain the situation and the effect that could have with the development of the green economy, the green jobs and the green life. He talks about the project of “Rio+20”, the issue of international environment governance. In the green economy model   the transparency in natural resource governance and the active promotion of public participation in decision-making are critical elements. In all discussion the author tender to use the plural pronoun “we” because he talks about the green economy in general and the what the society think about  this matter.

 

CDA - A speech by President Barroso in EESC Rio+20 side event

http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-12-486_en.htm


I have analyzed a speech by President of the EU Commission J. M. D. Barroso: “Civil society participation in sustainable development – the European perspective” in EECS Rio+20 event. The speech focuses on the sustainable development’s challenges and the benefits of the growing role of the civil society in promoting sustainable consumption and production.

First of all, the structure is very simple. The paragraphs are clearly separated and no longer than 3 lines.

He often addresses – three times -  to “Mr President, ladies and gentlemen”  as an anaphor.

There aren’t metaphors or antithesis in this speech, maybe because the speaker prefers sending a direct message of his thoughts. In fact, I think these are narrative instruments and they are more frequently in a story or in a novel.

President Barroso uses the singular personal pronoun I and rarely the plural pronoun we, just  when he focuses on beliefs and needs and in order to highlight the EU engagements: “we believe that the green economy is a key instrument…”.

At the beginning of this speech there is a list of three – “I greatly welcome […] I particularly welcome […] Thankfully I…” – and another one at the end – “That is what the planet needs. That is what our citizens deserve. And that is what future generations demand from us”. The list of three at the speech’s end highlights the emphasis for the future’s involvements and the necessity to address the action for human well-being. President Barroso is also proud of the opportunity to represent the EU in the meeting and of the support received from the UNO to the EU 2020 Strategy objectives.

Monday, 3 December 2012

The green economy – our survival strategy


This week I have chosen to analyse a speech EU Commissioner for environment, Janez Potočnik. Potočnik sustains that from 1990 there have been some social, politics but above all economic transformations, the development of the countries represents 35% of the GDP (Gross Domestic Product) in comparison to the 18% of the preceding years. He begins her discussion with a question: why the green economy? and the answer has been that the green economy is the only solution for our survival. Potočnik not only speaks from his point of view but from the point of view of the whole population, it always uses the plural pronoun “we”, for example:
  • “We will need to change the way we grow";
  •  "the way we use key resources";
  • "We need to create a new circular structure …”
And he continue all of his discussion using the plural pronoun “we”. In the first part he underlines that the poorest populations will suffer very more if we use the unsustainable resources but there are the means to defeat the challenges for the sustainable development, above all through the technology. it is really for this motive that the European union has 5 objectives that are at the base of a green economy: the water, the oceans, the earth, the sustainable energy and the efficiency of the resources; they are known as the “5 pillars of the life”. The second part concerns the world governance on the sustainable development and the European union it is the principal donor of helps in the world.

Sunday, 2 December 2012

"Only One Earth - don't waste it!"


This week I’ve chosen to analyse the opening speech of Green week of 2008. This speech was made by Stavros Dimas, a member of the European Commission, responsible for Environment.
Dimas is very direct and in fact he starts immediately to underline what Europe has done until that moment and to focus on the aim of the week:
“The first is that European environmental policies have delivered immense benefits to Europe's citizens. Their air is cleaner, their beaches and rivers are cleaner and pollutants such as lead in petrol have been banned. […] our environment policy is one of the success stories of European integration.”

“The second observation is that, just as it is right to celebrate these success stories, sometimes we need to take a step back and look at just how far we still are from a model of development that is genuinely sustainable."

Only in the first part of the speech Dimas uses the first person singular pronoun “I” ( “I believe we can get there.” / “Last week I represented the Commission at the UN biodiversity conference in Bonn [...]” ) not only in order to show his personal involvement on European agenda linked to this topic but also to express his personal hopes and s we will work closely with the retail sector .
In the rest part of the speech Dimas uses often the first personal plural pronoun “we”. Therefore I noticed that this pronoun has a range of reference:
  • It can refer to “I” and the Commission
    “we will propose the introduction of mandatory minimum standards for the most environmentally harmful products […]
    “we will work closely with the retail sector [...]”
  • It can refer to “I” plus the rest of Europe's citizens
    “And if we continue to emit greenhouse gases at current rates [..]”
    “we are still a long way from meeting our most basic environmental objectives [...]”
    “we have to take a fresh look at how we produce products and at how we use them [...]”.

Even if Dimas is very proud of the results and of the policies that Europe is creating and promoting, he is very realistic and often he repeats the fact that there is so many things that we have to do in order to protect our planet and to try to resolve environmental problems.
“There has been talk but not much action. “
“It is now time to go beyond rhetoric and begin putting in place the measures that can actually lead to a change in behavior.”
“we have to take a fresh look at how we produce products and at how we use them [...]”
“we need to step up action to put our economies onto a more sustainable footing and to 'do more with less “.

I noticed that the speaker often uses this kind of sentences. In my opinion he wants to underline the fact that everyone can do something on his own and I think the repetition of this idea is not accidental: he repeats this concept because he wants in the same time to convinced people and to fix this idea on their minds. But these sentences can also be seen as “claptrap” sentences too.
Besides I looked for the list of three in the text but I didn’t find many (“for food safety, car safety and toy safety, and introducing standards for environmental safety is only common sense”).
Instead the speaker used lots of repetitions to underline concepts such as: “green production/ lean production”, “Our consumption and production patterns / sustainable pattern of production and consumption” ,“good policy/new approach” “new idea/ new insights”.

In the end once again Dimas underlined the aim of the week and thanked everyone that was there for the Green Week.

http://www.eu-un.europa.eu/articles/en/article_7924_en.htm




Saturday, 1 December 2012

Critical Discourse Analysis




This week I have chosen to analyse a speech EU Commissioner for energy Guenther Oettinger gave at the 3rd Desert Energy Conference in Berlin. The speech focuses on the cooperation between MENA (Middle East and North African) countries and the European Union in energy matters. In other words, the creation of common or negotiated energy and infrastructural policies in order to make Mediterranean and European countries partners in the renewable energy market.
Apart from some cases, Commissioner Oettinger tended to use primarily the plural pronoun form “we”, when referring to the European Union, in order to underline that every decision is supported by other commissioners and by Member States, even though he is the one responsible for European energy policies. The plural pronoun form is also used to underline the need for cooperation and collaboration in this sector. Rarely he switched to the first person pronoun “I”, namely at the beginning  and at the end, when thanking the hosts and the audience. In another case “I” was used to propose to MENA countries’ governments to keep in mind European experience in this sector, when designing new renewable energy policies.
The speaker often used soundbites to capture the audience attention on the speech, usually using it to sum up the content of the following paragraph.

Although I looked for lists of three in the text, I found not so many of them: “different load profiles, different fuel mix, different back-up capacity for ..” to highlight the pros of creating a regional energy market in the Mediterranean area. To focus the audience’s attention on electricity market, the speaker repeats three times “integrated electricity market/integrated Mediterranean electricity market, regional electricity market” which in this context are synonyms.  Besides Instead the speaker used lots of repetitions to underline concepts such as “the development of renewables/the development of renewable energy sources”, “exchange/exchange” which is repeated twice in two adjacent sentences to highlight the need for cooperation between the EU and MENA countries.

Sunday, 25 November 2012

EU exporting more waste, including hazardous waste


The conversion of our models and economic behaviours towards sustainable development has become one of the priorities of EU policies. This change had an effect also on waste management, in fact garbage is the most tangible evidence that we are wasting lot of resources.

The movement of waste between EU member states, but also from the European Union to countries outside Europe, increased markedly between 1999 and 2011. This, in brief, are the contents of the report by the European Environment Agency "Movements of waste across the Eu's internal and external borders." During the period under review, the export of scrap iron, steel, copper, aluminium and nickel is doubled, the export of precious metals has tripled and that of plastic waste had increased fivefold. As we can read in the article between 2000 and 2009 also doubled the export of hazardous waste, including electronic waste, even if the volumes transported decreased in 2008 and 2009, probably because of the economic depression.
The increased movement of waste in Europe, according to the study there are positive and negative aspects. Among the first we should consider the fact that there are more opportunities for recovery and recycling, with benefits from an economic point of view (recovery of raw materials with lower cost), environmental point of view (disposal landfills and reducing the environmental impact), as well as the efficient use of resources (recycling reduces the pressure of human activities on environmental resources).
On the negative side, there are not only the increase of transport, which implies higher energy consumption and the emissions of greenhouse gases, but also negatives aspects linked to exports outside the EU: there are risks associated with the use of recycling and recovery processes which sometimes don't respect the environment and human health. Finally it must be added the risks of illegal trafficking of materials that lead to "dumping in a illegally way".
With regard to waste exported it would be necessary to overcome the lacks of Europe, both industrial, extending processes and disposal facilities for particular types of waste, and legislative harmonising laws and regulations, including rules in order to improve controls and combating illegal actions.



http://www.eea.europa.eu/highlights/eu-exporting-more-waste-
http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/movements-of-waste-EU-2012

Friday, 23 November 2012

The green economy: a style of life.


The green economy is the key to go out the crisis. This is what has told the last interview the minister of the environment, Corrado Clini. When we talk about green economy it  means to also have some changes to cultural level. The green economy, as was written in a articles puclished in 5/09/2012, is a style of life that realizes his trough the eco innovation. Eco innovation is a type of innovation that not only concerns the economic aspects but also the environmental and social context, the style of life and the dimension of a country. The UNEP (unitednations environmental programme), the organization that operates against the climatic changes for the environmental sustainability, has appraised the eco innovation and is emerged that the costs for this support will oscillate up to 1,5 trilions of dollar in 2012 and between the 3 and the 10 trilions in 2050. The objective of the eco innovation is the change toward the system of production and consumption. In 2011, according to the classification of the eco innovation to european level, italy occupies the 16 place against the 12 in 2010. Important element in italy is the consitution of a national plan for the development, diffusion and implementationof the eco innovation able to conjugate on one side the sustainable production and the efficientuse of the energy and on the other sidethe efficient use of the materials.

Elena Benfatto