Sunday, 2 December 2012

"Only One Earth - don't waste it!"


This week I’ve chosen to analyse the opening speech of Green week of 2008. This speech was made by Stavros Dimas, a member of the European Commission, responsible for Environment.
Dimas is very direct and in fact he starts immediately to underline what Europe has done until that moment and to focus on the aim of the week:
“The first is that European environmental policies have delivered immense benefits to Europe's citizens. Their air is cleaner, their beaches and rivers are cleaner and pollutants such as lead in petrol have been banned. […] our environment policy is one of the success stories of European integration.”

“The second observation is that, just as it is right to celebrate these success stories, sometimes we need to take a step back and look at just how far we still are from a model of development that is genuinely sustainable."

Only in the first part of the speech Dimas uses the first person singular pronoun “I” ( “I believe we can get there.” / “Last week I represented the Commission at the UN biodiversity conference in Bonn [...]” ) not only in order to show his personal involvement on European agenda linked to this topic but also to express his personal hopes and s we will work closely with the retail sector .
In the rest part of the speech Dimas uses often the first personal plural pronoun “we”. Therefore I noticed that this pronoun has a range of reference:
  • It can refer to “I” and the Commission
    “we will propose the introduction of mandatory minimum standards for the most environmentally harmful products […]
    “we will work closely with the retail sector [...]”
  • It can refer to “I” plus the rest of Europe's citizens
    “And if we continue to emit greenhouse gases at current rates [..]”
    “we are still a long way from meeting our most basic environmental objectives [...]”
    “we have to take a fresh look at how we produce products and at how we use them [...]”.

Even if Dimas is very proud of the results and of the policies that Europe is creating and promoting, he is very realistic and often he repeats the fact that there is so many things that we have to do in order to protect our planet and to try to resolve environmental problems.
“There has been talk but not much action. “
“It is now time to go beyond rhetoric and begin putting in place the measures that can actually lead to a change in behavior.”
“we have to take a fresh look at how we produce products and at how we use them [...]”
“we need to step up action to put our economies onto a more sustainable footing and to 'do more with less “.

I noticed that the speaker often uses this kind of sentences. In my opinion he wants to underline the fact that everyone can do something on his own and I think the repetition of this idea is not accidental: he repeats this concept because he wants in the same time to convinced people and to fix this idea on their minds. But these sentences can also be seen as “claptrap” sentences too.
Besides I looked for the list of three in the text but I didn’t find many (“for food safety, car safety and toy safety, and introducing standards for environmental safety is only common sense”).
Instead the speaker used lots of repetitions to underline concepts such as: “green production/ lean production”, “Our consumption and production patterns / sustainable pattern of production and consumption” ,“good policy/new approach” “new idea/ new insights”.

In the end once again Dimas underlined the aim of the week and thanked everyone that was there for the Green Week.

http://www.eu-un.europa.eu/articles/en/article_7924_en.htm




1 comment:

  1. I've found really interesting this speech, mainly for two reasons: first, it was held during the Green Week, that is an occasion of worldwide importance to capture audience's attention, and second, because of its formulation. In fact, Dimas starts underlining those great efforts that the EU has done to counteract pollution and promote a greener world, stressing that European environmental policy is one of the greatest success of the integration process. On the other hand, in the second part of the speech, he looks at the same problem from another point of view, wondering whether the development model proposed for our planet is truly sustainable. In this regard, when I've read the article, it has come to my mind a book that I've read two years ago, written by a famous Indian scientist, socially engaged in these topics, Vandana Shiva. In her book, "Soil Not Oil" she invites us to reflect on those so-called "green" or "environmental" policies, carried out by international institutions (such as the EU or the United Nations), that we believe to be useful for the pollution's reduction, instead they merely upset environment and people. I remeber the example she gives, explaining how rapeseed mono-crops in India have displaced pluri-crops, unsettling traditional agricolture and environment, and leading also people loosing their source of sustenance. From this book I've learned to look at policies that seem to be useful and effective always from another point of view. And this is the same thing Dimas was doing in his speech.

    ReplyDelete